Windoes Vista SP1 Release Candidate Review

The recently released Windows Vista SP1 Release Candidate (RC), like the previous beta, does more to improve the internal plumbing of Windows Vista than it does to make any major changes to the interface. SP1 RC targets performance, reliability, and security, leaving the operating system's features and functionality largely intact, with the exception of allowing […]

The recently released Windows Vista SP1 Release Candidate (RC), like the previous beta, does more to improve the internal plumbing of Windows Vista than it does to make any major changes to the interface. SP1 RC targets performance, reliability, and security, leaving the operating system's features and functionality largely intact, with the exception of allowing users to substitute an alternate search tool for the one built into Vista, and removing the Search link from the Start menu.

When the final version of SP1 (currently slated for next year) is released, the big news will be the death of the so-called Kill Switch, which Microsoft prefers to call "reduced functionality mode." Whatever you call it, though, the elimination of the switch will be good news. Currently, if you don't activate your retail copy of Windows Vista after 30 days, your desktop turns black, and your icons and the Start menu vanish. You can't open your files (although you can copy them). You're able to use a Web browser for only an hour before you get logged off.

The same thing happens if Windows Vista decides that you've installed it on a different PC than your original one, and you ignore a three-day grace period for contacting Microsoft. Vista might also decide it's been installed on a different PC than the original if you make a substantial number of hardware changes to your original PC.

In the shipping version of SP1 (though not in the current RC version), the Kill Switch will become more of a "Nudge Switch." You'll be frequently reminded that you need to activate Windows, and the desktop background will turn black. Try to change it to another background, and an hour later Windows will turn it black again. In addition, you won't be able to download signed drivers and optional updates via Windows Updates, although you'll still be able to get critical security updates. Not a pleasant experience, certainly, but at least you'll still be able to use the operating system.

For more details about the Kill Switch and new antipiracy measures baked into SP1, read our article "Microsoft to beef up antipiracy checks in Vista SP1.

Changes since the previous beta: Not much has changed in the RC version of SP1 compared to the previous beta, although there are slight differences. Installation on my 1.83-GHz Core Duo laptop took under an hour; the previous beta took an hour and 15 minutes. The previous beta didn't clean up after itself, and left about 1GB worth of files in a folder that was no longer needed after installation. RC, on the other hand, deletes that directory and files.

A bug I found in the previous beta still remains: On my home network, which uses a Linksys WRT54GX4 router, I couldn't connect from my SP1 RC test machine to any other Vista PCs on my network. And I couldn't connect from Vista PCs to the test machine, either. However, I could connect to XP machines, and from XP machines to my test machine. That bug appears to be an isolated one, because other reviewers have been able to connect to Vista PCs on their networks.

Overall, in RC, Vista seems a little zippier when it connects to XP PCs. Copying files between PCs seems faster, and the time estimates that Vista gives for how long that copying will take seem to be more accurate.

Microsoft claims there have been other, minor changes as well, including a reduction in the size of stand-alone installers. It says that the RC stand-alone installer packages with 36 languages are 50% smaller than the previous beta, and the stand-alone installer packages with five languages are 30% smaller. In addition, the company says, disk space required for installation has decreased, and in RC, if SP1 discovers there's not enough space to install, it will tell you how much extra space you need. Microsoft also claims that the installation is more reliable, with a higher percentage of successful installs.

Full Review

Windows Vista, Service Pack, SP1, Vista SP1, Release Candidate, Microsoft, Review